• Indexing List

Rama Raju, Sherikar, and CH Srinivas.: Body fat distribution and its effect on vital capacity index in young adults


Introduction

Obesity has been increasing in prevalence and is predisposing factor for many illness like cardiovascular disease,type 2 diabetes, hypercholesterolemia, asthma and cancer.1 Excessive abdominal fat distribution has been associated with higher levels of total cholesterol, serum triglycerides and low density lipoproteins(atherogenic lipoprotein profile) which in turn contribute to further more cardiovascular risk.2 Body fat of men will be distributed mainly abdominal when compared to woman of reproductive age group.3 Breathing is vital for survival, and any changes in respiratory function will have an effect on performance of regular activities. Past studies have shown that fat is related to impaired metabolism, along with reduction in pulmonary volumes such as total lung capa city and vital capacity.4 Obesity is a possible risk factor for exercise intolerance, and also for the development of COPD.

Body mass index (BMI, calculated as weight in kilograms divided by height in meter square) greater than 24 are considered as overweight, BMI> 28 considered as obese has been negatively related to lung functions such as forced expiratory volume in first second (FEV1), and forced vital capacity (FVC). Increased anthropometric parameters like waist circumference (WtC), waist-to-hip ratio (WtHR), and also total body fat percentage (BFP) which indicates body proportion are inversely correlated with impaired lung functions.5 The accumulation of abdominal fat is determined mainly by IA AT deposition and to a lesser extent by ScAT. Compared with ScAT, IA AT is believed to be more important in developing the insulin resistance, lipid abnormalities, and inflammation.6

Men aged between 50 -70 years with metabolic syndrome shows a inverse correlation between visceral fat, BMI, WC with FEV1, and FVC.7 In previous studies the correlations between VCI and Body fat distribution were analysed in either people above 50years or people with metabolic syndrome. Whether these correlations apply to the healthy adults is to assessed by this study. In the current study, we included 164 medical students to analyze the associations between fat distribution and lung functions as there are less chances of age related changes and metabolic syndromes. The BMI, BFP, WtHR, IA AT, ScAT, and vital capacity index (VCI, taken as a standard for lung function ) were measured. We analyzed the association between lung function and IA AT, ScAT, BMI, BFP, and WtHR in young adults. These correlations were also analyzed individually between males and females to know the gender differences in fat distribution that affect the lung function.

Materials and Methods

A total of 164 medical students of GSL Medical college, aged 18-23 in which 93 were females and 71 were males were taken into study. The study was explained and informed consent was taken from individual participant. Participants with respiratory, cardiovascular diseases and previous history of anti tuberculosis medication, smoking history.any history of chest trauma and major surgeries were excluded from the study. Weight and height of the individuals were taken where the individual is having light weight clothing and with no foot wear. Height was me asured in centimetres by height chart and weight in kg by using digital weighing machine. Waist-to - hip ratio, is the ratio of circumference of the waist to circumference of the hips. Waist circumference was measured by taking the mid point between lowest palpable rib and top of iliac crest (approximately at the point of umbilicus) while the H ip measurement is at the widest part of buttocks with measuring tape. BMI was calculated as weight divided by square of height in meters(Kg/m2).

Body fat compositions were measured using Omron Karada scan – body composition monitor model HBF- 375. This device uses biochemical impedance to estimate fat percentage. Depending on where fat is accumulated it is divided into Intra abdominal adipose tissue(IAAT) and Subcutaneous adipose tissue(ScAT). Vital capacity was estimated using alpha vitalograph spirometer. The students were instructed to have 3 to 4 normal tidal breathes and then deep inspiration and slow expiration as long as they can. Three readings were taken and the maximum reading is taken as final reading. As vital capacity is affected by posture all the recordings were taken in standing position with neck slightly extended. Vital capacity is also influenced by height and weight of the individual vital capacity is converted into vital capacity index by dividing vital capacity with body weight in Kilograms(ml/kg).

Results were presented as mean + Standard Deviation. Statistical analysis was performed using the SPSS version 20.0 software. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to assess the statistical significance, P <0.05 was taken as statistically significant the correlation between VCI and Body fat indices was done by Pearson’s correlation correlation relation factor r is calculated and is analysed as r < 0 is negatively correlated, r=0 is nil significant r >0 positive correlation.

Results

A total 164 students were taken into study. Their age, body compositions and vital capacity index are tabulated as mean and standard deviations in Table 1

Table 1
Parameter Total(164) Men (71) Women(93) P value
Age (years) 19.90 + 1.467 20.01 + 1.492 19.88 + 1.465 0.577
Height (cm) 160.97 + 7.30 169.02 + 5.882 157.71 + 4.896 0.000*
Weight (kg) 51.34 + 8.256 58.76 + 8.877 48.31 + 5.723 0.000*
BMI 19.73 + 2.302 20.52 + 2.655 19.43 + 2.067 0.003*
WtHR 0.81 + 0.043 0.87 + 0.367 0.77 + 0.247 0.038*
BFP(%) 20.44 + 7.036 12.89 + 5.534 23.54 + 4.916 0.000*
ScAT(kg) 9.71 + 3.795 7.05 + 3.835 10.76 + 3.212 0.000*
IAAT(kg) 0.84 + 0.619 0.86 + 0.857 0.81 + 0.485 0.637
VCI(ml/kg) 55.88 + 11.497 62.81 + 11.613 53.07 + 10.173 0.000*

Body compositions and vital index in the participants

[i] BMI- Body Mass Index, WtHR -Waist Hip Ratio, BFP-Body Fat percentage, ScAT-subcutaneous adipose tissue, IAAT-Intra abdominal adipose tissue, VCI-Vital Capacity index

[ii] *P<0.05 is statistically significant

As revealed from Table 1 male participants showed significantly higher BMI, WtHR, VCI, compared with females. Female participants showed relatively more BFP, ScAT than males. There was no significant difference in IAAT between females and males.

Correlation of body indices and vital capacity index for both males and females were done using pearson’s corr elation. r value and p value were calculated .

Table 2
Parameter Men Women
r value p value r value p value
BFP -0.384 <0.01* -0.332 <0.01*
IAAT -0.465 <0.01* -0.325 <0.01*
ScAT -0.413 <0.01* -0.354 <0.01*
BMI -0.453 <0.01* -0.332 <0.01*
WtHR -0.376 <0.01* -0.335 <0.01*

Pearson’s correlation analysis between body composition indices and vital capacity index

[i] BFP-Body Fat percentage, IAAT-Intra abdominal adipose tissue, ScAT-subcutaneous adipose tissue, , BMI- Body Mass Index, WtHR-Waist Hip Ratio.

[ii] *p<0.05 is statistically significant, r<0 negatively correlated

As evident from table 2 males body indices such as BFP, IA AT, ScAT, BMI, WtHR showed negative correlation with VCI (r<0, P<0.01). Females showed similar result as men.

Discussion

In the present study 164 medical students were recruited to study the effects of abdominal fat distribution on lung function.we found that abdomin al fat parameters such as BFP, IAAT, ScAT are negatively correlated with Vital capacity index in both males and females. Abdominal fat distribution has been associated with type 2 diabetes, coronary heart disease, irritable syndrome and also impaired lung functions. In a similar study IAAT, BMI, Waist circumference are inversely associated with impaired lung function in men aged 50-70 years with the metabolic syndrome.7 In another study by Capelo AV et al8 lung functions were inversely associated with visceral adiposity in females of mean age 55.39 years with Bronchial asthma.

The above cited two studies have their limitations as the subjects were aged more than 50 may be having metabolic syndrome or age related impairment of lung function. So it is unclear with these studies whether there is direct correlation between visceral adipose tissue and lung functions .so to avoid the age related and metabolic syndrome related confusion, we recruited young adults to know the correlation between visceral adipose tissue and lung function. College students of aged eighteen to twenty three years were believed to be matured enough physically and psychologically. Thus college student subjects who falls under young age and with no much age related changes and metabolic syndromes might enhance the validity of the analysis.

There are two ways of estimating body fat composition, one is Dual energy X-ray absorpometry (DXA) and the other one is bioelectric impedance analysis(BIA). Out of the two methods DXA is the gold standard for estimating body fat indices.9 However Bioelectric impedance is taken here for analysing the body fat composition because of the following reasons. DXA has a risk of radiation exposure which may psychologically manipulate the subjects willing to participate in the study.DXA is costlier and is not feasible for such a number of participants. Bioelectric impedance is easy and no radiation exposure, cheaper, expertise technician need not be required for the analysis. In a study done by Najate A et al. concluded that DXA and BIA can be used interchangeably at population level.10

Fat distribution varies with gender, women are typically having more SAT ,where as men are having additional VAT,11 which is also in according to our study, though there was additional IAAT in men however it's not statistically significant. The variations in body fat composition of men and women may be mainly due to hormonal and life style changes. For example oestrogen in females will increase the deposition of more ScAT than IAAT.12 Central obesity which leads to visceral fat accumulation in thorax and abdomen have a tendency to reduce the movements of diaphragm and chest cavity, while peripheral obesity have relatively low effect.13 Not only fat distribution of both the genders but also difference in lung morphology and hormones also effect the lung function.14 In the current study VCI is inversely correlated with BFP, IAAT, ScAT in each the genders, however VCI is more negatively correlated with IAAT in males and ScAT in females, suggesting a gender difference in fat distribution and its impact on lung functions confirming our hypotheis.15,16 contrary to our study park et al. Study have shown IA AT has shown more negative correlation than SAT in females of mean age group 53.4 years.17 Probabilities for this contradiction may be the age taken in their study was almost post menopausal which may lead to accumulation of visceral fat.

In this study not only IAAT, ScAT, w e also studied the correlation between BFP, WtHR, BMI and VCI which is also inversely correlated. Increase in BMI, BFP, WtHR has been associated with the accumulation of excessive fat within the abdominal cavity and on chest wall. This accumulation of fat in the abdominal cavity and on the chest wall restricts the movements of diaphragm as well as chest wall which can lead to the decrease in Vital capacity, decreasing the pulmonary volumes, increasing the work of respiratory muscles, and eventually affecting the gaseous exchange.18 In the present study there is also gender variations in WtHR, BMI, VCI relatively more in males except BFP which was more in women.

The study has some limitations like only VCI was taken, FVC, FEV1, FEV1/FVC were not taken because of the complexity . Another limitation is its a cross–sectional study which lacks the analysis about the other probable causes for the alteration of lung functions.

Conclusion

The above done study has showed significant inverse correlation between abdominal fat distribution and vital capacity index in young adults of both genders. IAAT is more negatively associated with VCI in males, where as ScAT in females.

Source of funding

None.

Conflict of interest

None.

References

1 

A H Mokdad E S Ford B A Bowman W H Dietz F Vinicor V S Bales Prevalence of obesity, diabetes, and obesity-related health risk factorsJAMA200328917679

2 

S H Scheuer K Faerch A Philipsen Abdominal fat distribution and cardiovascular risk in men and women with different levels of glucose toleranceJ Clin Endocrinol Metab2015100933403347

3 

S Lemieux D Prudhomme C Bouchard A Tremblay J P Despres Sex differences in the relation of visceral adipose tissue to total body fatnessAm J Clin Nutr1993584463467

4 

E 4. Ceylan A Cmlekii A Akkolu C Ceylan O Itil G Ergr The effects of body fat distribution on pulmonary function tests in overweight and obeseSouth Med J200910213035

5 

S Koziel S J Ulijaszek A Szklarska T Bielicki The effects of fatness and fat distribution on respiratory functionsAnn Hum Biol2007341123154

6 

A Festa D Agostino R Jr K Williams A J Karter E J Mayer-Davis R P Tracy S M Haffner The relation of body fat mass and distribution to markers of chronic inflammationInt J Obes Relat Metab Disord20012514071415

7 

W Thijs R A Dehnavi P S Hiemstra Association of lung function measurements and visceral fat in men with metabolic syndromeRespir Med20141082351358

8 

Da Capelo A V V M Fonseca M V M Peixoto Visceral adiposity is associated with cytokines and decrease in lung function in women with persistent asthmaRev Port Pneumol2016225255261

9 

L K Micklesfield J Evans S A Norris Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry and anthropometric estimates of visceral fat in Black and White South African WomenObesity2012183619624

10 

S Leahy C O&apos;neill R Sohun P Jakeman A comparison of dual energy X-ray absorptiometry and bioelectrical impedance analysis to measure total and segmental body composition in healthy young adultsEur J Appl Physiol20121122589595589-95.10.1007/s00421-011-2010-4

11 

Y Jinrong L Lei S Jihong Analysis of human body composition and its correlation with obesity in 555 college studentsChinese School Physicians20163011815821

12 

Dong Wenyan Qiu Yao - Shun The expression of estrogen receptor in adipocytes and its correlation with fat distribution in human bodyChin J Aesthetic Med20051405534536

13 

S W Littleton Impact of obesity on respiratory functionRespirol2012171434910.1111/j.1440-1843.2011.02096.x

14 

R Ross P T Katzmarzyk Cardiorespiratory fitness is associated with diminished total and abdominal obesity independent of body mass indexInt J Obes Relat Metab Disord200327204210

15 

I Janssen P T Katzmarzyk R Ross A S Leon J S Skinner D C Rao Fitness alters the associations of BMI and waist circumference with total and abdominal fatObes Res200412525537

16 

Huang Efeects of fat distribution on lung function in young adultsJ Physioll Anthropol20193877

17 

Y S Park H T Kwon S S Hwang Impact of visceral adiposity measured by abdominal computed tomography on pulmonary functionJ Korean Med Sci2011266771777

18 

S M Koenig S M Koenig Pulmonary complications of obesityAm J Med Sci20013214249279



jats-html.xsl